Story at-a-glance
- Third-year medical education is evolving, with growing debate between traditional block rotations and longitudinal integrated clerkships (LICs).
- Block rotations offer broad exposure, but critics compare the brief experiences to “speed-dating” with specialties.
- LICs provide continuity, allowing students to follow the same patients and work with consistent mentors for a year.
- The AMA supports LICs for their emphasis on patient-centered care and deeper physician-patient relationships.
- As education models shift, medical students must also plan financially—with disability insurance offering vital income protection.
Medical students dedicate years to mastering their craft, preparing for both the challenges of patient care and their financial future. We’ve emphasized the importance of securing physician disability insurance early to protect against financial risks, including unpaid student loans.
However, beyond financial planning, medical students and experienced physicians are reassessing the structure of third-year medical education. Many now advocate for integrating longitudinal integrated clerkships (LICs) into the curriculum instead of the traditional clinical block rotations.
The Traditional Third-Year Model
Historically, third-year medical students gain clinical experience through block rotations. These short-term placements introduce them to various specialties, giving a broad but brief exposure to different fields. According to The New York Times Well Blog, this method has been compared to “speed-dating” with different medical disciplines.
While this approach allows exposure to multiple specialties, critics argue that it limits meaningful interactions with both senior physicians and patients. This lack of continuity can hinder a deeper understanding of long-term patient care.
The Case for Longitudinal Integrated Clerkships
LICs take a different approach. Instead of rotating every few weeks, students follow the same patients for a full year, observing everything from inpatient treatments to outpatient visits. This structure allows medical students to witness disease progression firsthand, fostering a stronger connection to patient care.
According to the American Medical Association, LICs help students develop a deeper commitment to their patients and provide consistent mentorship by working with the same faculty and peers throughout the year.
Which Model is Best for Medical Students?
Longitudinal clerkships have existed for decades, but their role in modern medical education is growing. More schools are considering them as a way to train medical students with a patient-centered perspective.
Would you prefer the continuity of LICs or the broad exposure of clinical rotations?
Ready to protect your future?
Get a personalized side-by-side policy comparison of the leading disability insurance companies from an independent insurance broker.
